“South Africa’s Battle Over Booze And The Price Of Drinking”
2 Oceans Vibe reports:
“South Africa’s love affair with booze is costing the country dearly – from hospitals overflowing with alcohol-related trauma cases to children growing up in households where weekend benders start on Monday.
“Now, with the nation under pressure to sober up, the battle over how to tackle harmful drinking is heating up.
“At the centre of the storm is a hotly contested idea called Minimum Unit Pricing (MUP), which would jack up alcohol prices to curb binge drinking, per the Saturday Star.
“Anti-drug NPO World Changers candidate Luca Mahlakgane is calling foul on the entire policy-making process. ‘One of the issues we face is that much of the policy drafting is done by alcohol companies themselves, which they then pass to Parliament for approval. From where we stand, the issue of alcohol is not even debatable,’ he snapped, accusing lawmakers of being far too cosy with Big Booze.”
“South Africa grapples with harmful drinking policies amid rising alcohol consumption”
IOL reports:
“Anti-drug-focused NPO World Changers candidate Luca Mahlakgane vehemently denounced the MUP idea, stating that the crafting of such policies often stems from the very alcohol companies they aim to regulate. ‘One of the issues we face is that much of the policy drafting is done by alcohol companies themselves, which they then pass to Parliament for approval. From where we stand, the issue of alcohol is not even debatable,’ he remarked, highlighting a disconnect between legislative action and ground realities.
“Mahlakgane also emphasised the daily struggles within communities affected by alcohol and substance abuse. ‘When you try to make everything academic, you lose a lot of points. Just step outside, and you will see people drinking from Monday to Friday. South African laws have normalised drinking; it has become a lifestyle. Children grow up in families where drinking is commonplace, leading to early access to alcohol,’ he noted.”
“South Africa debates minimum unit pricing as alcohol harm sparks policy divide”
The Farmers Journal reports:
“The debate has attracted sharp, personal interventions. Lucas Mahlakgane of the non-profit World Changers has accused the policy process of being overly influenced by industry drafting, arguing that ordinary communities are not properly heard on this issue. His criticism taps into a broader suspicion that powerful interests shape the rules they then have to obey.
“At the same time, South African Breweries and other major companies have said they are engaging with government to find balanced solutions that protect jobs and the fiscus while reducing harm. They have called for predictable tax systems that do not unduly burden consumers or penalize smaller producers. Those calls highlight how any change to pricing will ripple through the formal economy.
“David Harrison, chief executive of the DG Murray Trust, frames the issue differently. He points to the social drivers behind drinking, saying that misery and lack of alternatives in poorer communities make it far harder for people to drink responsibly. His view is that tackling structural problems like poverty, lack of recreation and community support will do more to reduce harm than price tools alone.”
Assessment
The alcohol industry has been very active in polluting the media discourse, pushing its usual themes of illicit trade and jobs. The alcohol industry is creating a false, misleading, and factually wrong dichotomy between protecting jobs and the fiscus while reducing harm – revealing their conflict of interest. Raising alcohol prices to reduce affordability through raising alcohol taxes has a quadruple positive effect on preventing and reducing harm and costs, raising government revenue, improving employment, productivity and economic growth, and promoting social justice and equity.
Importantly, advocates have improved the public discourse by ensuring that the media also reflects the reality of alcohol harm and the urgent need for effective policy. This shows the impact of sustained advocacy that combines lived experience, compelling evidence, and clear messaging.
Alcohol policy advocates have an opportunity to move the public debate forward by a) exposing the alcohol industry’s conflict of interest more clearly, b) exposing the industry’s policy interference and capture, and c) showing the broad public concern about alcohol harm and support for alcohol policy (including taxation) action by the government. Framing alcohol taxation as key tool to prevent and reduce alcohol harm and protect communities is evidence-based and community-supported and thus should inform the public discourse.