The Senate’s Constitution and Justice Committee has approved a bill that increases prison sentences for people who sell or provide alcohol to children and adolescents.
In itself, this legislation would be inadequate in really protecting children from pervasive alcohol harm and alcohol normalisation. But this could be an opportunity to inform the public discourse about how alcohol harm affects children and how to prevent this harm in the most cost-effective and comprehensive ways.

“Bill increases penalties for selling or offering alcohol to minors”

Rádio Senado reports:

“People who supply children and adolescents with alcoholic beverages or other products that cause physical or psychological dependence can now be convicted and imprisoned for 2 to 4 years. A bill approved by the Constitution and Justice Committee (CCJ) provides for this penalty to be increased by up to 50 per cent if it is confirmed that the minor consumed the product purchased (PL 942/2024). The rapporteur for the bill, Senator Margareth Buzetti (Independent-MT), stated that alcohol consumption in childhood can leave marks on a citizen’s entire life. The proposal will now be reviewed by the full Senate.”

Assessment

The bill reflects growing recognition in Brazil’s political arena that protecting children and adolescents from alcohol harm requires more action and much more comprehensive measures than the country is implementing thus far.

More severe penalties for behavior related to alcohol that can harm children send a clear message to the public and might contribute to denormalising alcohol in Brazilian childhoods.

But social norms are better shaped by population-level policy measures that affect the environment of people, especially children, families, and communities – for example making alcohol less affordable, protecting children from alcohol marketing, and placing common-sense limits of alcohol availability to create healthier and safer environments where children play, learn, and grow up.

This legislative initiative has positive elements in recongising how alcohol harm affects children and the need to protect them much better. But penalties alone will not solve the problem. The focus on the role of parents alone is also too narrow and risks missing commercial drivers of alcohol harm in children.

Therefore, the Senate debate opens a relevant opportunity for a) informing the public discourse about how alcohol harm affects children and b) highlighting the urgent need for broader and evidence-based policy solutions to prevent that harm and to properly protect children in Brazil from alcohol industry products and practices.