“82% of Brazilians Agree That Having a Barbecue and Drinking a Beer With Friends and Family Should Be Accessible to Everyone”
O Globo (Lauro Jardim) reports:
“The government’s retreat on the regulation of the ‘sin tax,’ which will apply from 2027 to alcoholic beverages and other products harmful to health, was no accident.
“An internal survey by Instituto Locomotiva, which reached the knowledge of Lula’s aides, shows that 82% of Brazilians agree that ‘having a barbecue and drinking a beer with friends and family should be accessible to everyone.’ And for 74%, this type of activity is expensive.”
Other Articles on the Same Topic
- Lula Wants to Delay “Sin Tax” Proposal to Avoid Electoral Damage (Gazeta do Povo)
- Fear of “Expensive Beer”: Government Postpones Sin Tax Until After the Elections (BNews)
- Selective Tax Could Cost the Government Another Political Defeat (Metrópoles)
- Beer Sector Urges Quick Decision on Selective Tax Burden (Correio Braziliense)
Assessment
The survey that has likely influenced the Lula government’s decision to postpone the Selective Tax bill until after the October 2026 elections warrants scrutiny
Where does the survey come from?. O Globo describes it as an “internal” study by Instituto Locomotiva that “reached the knowledge” of Lula’s aides. Instituto Locomotiva is a commercial polling firm – it produces surveys for paying clients, not pro bono. An “internal” survey likely means someone commissioned and paid for this research. How it ended up in the president’s inner circle at a politically decisive moment – just as the Treasury had finalised the Selective Tax bill – is itself a question worth asking.
The question design points in a clear direction. Asking whether having a barbecue and drinking a beer with friends and family “should be accessible to everyone” is not a neutral research question. It is framed to produce near-universal agreement, which is then linked to the cost of these activities and, by implication, to taxation.
This mirrors the approach of a 2024 Instituto Locomotiva survey that was publicly promoted by Sindcerv, the beer industry front group whose board is supplied by Ambev (AB InBev) and Heineken Brasil – the two companies that control roughly 85% of Brazilian beer production. In that survey, Sindcerv president Márcio Maciel served as the spokesperson for the findings, using them to push for “tax burden neutrality” – the position that the total tax on beer should not increase under the reform. Neither the 2024 survey nor the new one referenced by O Globo appears on Instituto Locomotiva’s public studies page, suggesting both were produced for clients rather than as independent research.
The claim that beer is becoming unaffordable for Brazilians does not withstand scrutiny. WHO data shows that at 2.28%, the excise tax share on Brazilian beer is the lowest in the Region of the Americas.
According to Lauro Jardim, the Selective Tax bill – already formatted by the Treasury – will now be sent to Congress only after the elections. Government allies concluded that the opposition would exploit “expensive beer” as a campaign theme. Under Brazilian law, a new tax can only be collected in the year following its approval. If the bill does not pass Congress in 2026, implementation shifts from 2027 to 2028 – extending by another year the period during which alcohol products remain ultra cheap and grossly undertaxed.
The delay in the Selective Tax has been known for some time, but the mechanism is now more visible. The alcohol industry has built an interlocking set of tools to shape the reform in its favour:
- industry-funded Euromonitor reports to stoke fears of illicit trade,
- public opinion polling that frames any tax increase as an attack on Brazilian culture, and
- direct aggressive lobbying for alcohol tax rate caps.
Meanwhile, the ABBD – the spirits industry front group representing Diageo, Pernod Ricard, Bacardi, and Beam Suntory – is buying advertorial space in O Globo to push its own positioning on rate design, recycling the same Euromonitor illicit trade figures in paid content presented to resemble independent journalism.
Each tactic reinforces the others. The postponement makes monitoring and exposing these alcohol industry interference tactics all the more important. The delay does not change the underlying case for raising alcohol taxes in Brazil, it only extends the window in which advocates need to keep up the drum beat for the Selective Tax rates that the evidence calls for.
For advocates, this case highlights the importance of shaping the information environment with independent and representative survey findings that show in Brazil, 62% agree that higher taxation on alcohol would effectively help reducing consumption and 62% support alcohol price increases. 61% endorse taxes to reduce alcohol consumption. These figures would also need to reach government officials and circulate in the media and public discourse to counter Big Alcohol’s pollution of the discourse.