“Healthy taxes and front-of-pack labelling did not affect employment in Colombia”
El Espectador reports:
“A study on the 2022-2024 reforms shows that taxes on sugary drinks and ultra-processed foods, as well as warning stamps, did not cause layoffs or drops in income, as warned by unions such as Fenalco or ANDI.”
“Study ruled out negative impact of healthy taxes on employment and companies in the country, as predicted by some unions”
Infobae reports:
“The introduction of healthy taxes and front warning labeling on products with a high content of sugar, sodium, saturated fat or calories, which came into force in November 2023, was a regulation that at the time generated criticism, debate and concern about its possible negative impact on the business economy, from small businesses to large industries in the country.
“Among the most recurring arguments is the idea that taxing these products would affect sales and jobs, even leading to the closure of companies. However, an investigation led by the University of Rosario, and a team of national and international experts, maintains that these measures have not caused a labor or business crisis in the country, as the most pessimistic predicted.
“According to statements by Paul Rodríguez, economist at the aforementioned university, to El Espectador, food health policies can coexist with job and business stability, allowing progress towards healthier consumption without harming the industry.”
Assessment
A study led by the University of Rosario assessed the labour and business impacts of Colombia’s 2022–2024 pro-health tax reforms, including taxes on sugary drinks and ultra-processed foods and the introduction of front-of-pack warning labels. The analysis found no evidence of job losses, income declines, or widespread business closures following implementation. These scientific findings reveal the lies and misleading claims made ahead of the health reforms by powerful business lobbyists such as Fenalco and ANDI. Fenalco and ANDI represent powerful commercial interests in retail, manufacturing, and consumer goods, including global alcohol producers. Their opposition to health taxes reflects longstanding industry strategies that frame public health measures as economic threats, despite limited evidence that such impacts materialise.
The relevance for alcohol policy is immediate and substantial. In Colombia and globally, the alcohol industry consistently deploys the same economic and employment claims to delay or derail alcohol tax increases and other evidence-based policies, often claiming that higher taxes will destroy jobs, harm small businesses, or destabilise entire sectors. The findings of this study show that these claims did not materialise once the policies were implemented. And they underline the findings of a previous study showing employment gains from alcohol tax increases.
For decision makers, this research strengthens the case for treating alcohol industry economic claims with scepticism, particularly when they are presented as reasons to delay or dilute alcohol tax reform.
The Colombian experience demonstrates that health-oriented taxes can be introduced without undermining employment, while contributing to improved population health outcomes. This evidence can be used proactively to counter similar claims from the alcohol industry, reframing the debate around policy impact rather than industry forecasts, and supporting more ambitious alcohol taxation as both economically and socially responsible.
Evidence from the United States reinforces this pattern. A peer-reviewed study examined the employment impacts of alcohol tax increases across multiple U.S. states using macroeconomic modelling. The study found that alcohol tax increases were linked with net job gains, as reduced alcohol expenditure and increased public revenue shifted spending toward other sectors of the economy.
Close