The issue of concern: The delegation of the European Union to South Africa has invited major alcohol industry front groups and alcohol producers in Europe to jointly interfere in the development of alcohol policy solutions by the South African government.
The issue was first brought to public attention by the European Alcohol Policy Alliance (Eurocare).
The products and practices of the alcohol industry in South Africa are causing massive harm. These alcohol problems are of such magnitude that the government had decided three times during the coronavirus crisis to ban the sale of alcohol temporarily – a measures that showed substantial reductions in alcohol harm. Now, evidence-based alcohol policy development has risen to the highest level of political attention in South Africa.
– Joint Open Letter to European and Africa Leaders –
Civil society concern about European Union External Action request of the alcohol industry to interfere in a sovereign country’s public policy making
H.E. Dr. Ursula von der Leyen, President, European Commission,
H.E. Josep Borrell Fontelles, EU High Representative/Vice President,
H.E. Jutta Urpilainen, Commissioner, International Partnerships,
H.E. Moussa Faki Mahamat, Chairperson, African Union Commission,
H.E. Matamela Cyril Ramaphosa, President, Republic of South Africa
It is with utmost respect that we send you this letter.
We are community-based and civil society groups from Africa, Europe and around the world and we wish to express our deep concern about revelations that the European Union External Action is encouraging and even part-funding the alcohol industry to interfere in public policy making of a sovereign country, in this particular case South Africa.
The e-mail from the European Union’s representation in South Africa to European alcohol producers and their lobby front groups seeking to make profits in Africa is very disturbing.
It is grossly irresponsible and reckless on the part of the European Union External Action to be offering part-funding and encouraging joint activities around alcohol policy in South Africa, clearly trying to supplant and subvert the role of an African government which has been doing well in trying to contain COVID-19 through evidence-based alcohol policy solutions, including temporary alcohol sales bans.
Considering the lethal interaction between alcohol and the coronavirus pandemic specifically and in general alcohol’s role as a major obstacle to development, the revealed plans of the European Union External Action to collude with the alcohol industry are appalling.
As communities from around the world, we stand in solidarity with our brothers and sisters in South Africa and across the African continent where the products and practices of the alcohol industry are wreaking havoc.
- Together, we call on the European Union External Action to apologize to the people of South Africa.
- Together, we urge the European Union External Action to terminate any effort to support and coordinate with the alcohol industry to interfere in public policy making aimed at protecting people from the harms and suffering the alcohol industry is causing.
- Together we request the European Union and its Member States to end subsidizing the alcohol industry and their unethical business practices in Africa and around the world.
Multinational alcohol corporations, many of which are headquartered in Europe, have been exposed for their long track record of unethical business conduct and for numerous cases of derailing, delaying and destroying initiatives to protect African communities and societies from alcohol harm.
The e-mail of the collusion between the European Union External Action and Big Alcohol against the people of South Africa provides insights into activities that are likely taking place in other African countries.
It is very disturbing that the European Union External Action – especially during the raging global pandemic – seeks to advance private profit interests over public health and the well-being of the people of South Africa, by protecting the commercial interests of its multinational alcohol giants at the expense of sustainable development of South African society.
- Africa is already the region with the disproportionately greatest burden of alcohol harm, even though the majority of the adult population in African countries does not consume alcohol.
- In South Africa the combined tangible and intangible costs of alcohol harm to the economy reached nearly 300 billion rand or 10 to 12% of the 2009 GDP.
- 65% of women experiencing intimate partner violence in Uganda, Zimbabwe and South Africa reported that the perpetrator had used alcohol.
The products and practices of the alcohol industry in the African region have been projected to fuel rising alcohol harm. It would mean that gains made in South Africa in containing the spread of COVID-19 will be reversed. In the even larger picture, it will mean that the targets of the sustainable development goals will remain out of reach for African countries.
Therefore, we call on political leaders in South Africa and across the African continent to reject alcohol industry interference. We are with you in standing up to attempts which undermine and derail legitimate efforts to prevent and reduce alcohol harm thus promoting development and health for all.
Tungamirai Zimonte, Board member, Movendi International, Zimbabwe
Kristina Sperkova, International President, Movendi International, Slovakia
Tiziana Codenotti, President, European Alcohol Policy Alliance (Eurocare), Brussels, Belgium
Philip Chimponda, Chairperson, Southern African Alcohol Policy Alliance (SAAPA)
Bongi Ndondo, Chairperson, SAAPA South Africa
Thabo Mokhutsoane, Chairperson, and Mothobi Molefi, Country Coordinator, Southern Alfrican Alcohol Policy Alliance – Lesotho Chapter
Chief Masimba Biriwasha, Chairperson, SAAPA Zimbabwe
Prisca Mokgadi, Chairperson, SAAPA Botswana
Willemina Mberira, Chairperson, SAAPA Namibia
Siyanda Makhubo, Strategy and Communications Secretary, Independent Order of True Templars (I.O.T.T.), South Africa, Northern Botswana and Zimbabwe
Kiriba Kariuki, Organizing Secretary, East Africa Alcohol Policy Alliance (EAAPA)
Dr Franklin C. Umenze; Board Chairman, Western African Alcohol Policy Alliance (WAAPA)
Philip Nyakundi, Chairperson, Alcohol Control and Policy Network, Kenya
Dr. Kalema David, Chairperson, Uganda Alcohol Policy Alliance (UAPA), Uganda
Sophia Komba, Chairperson, Tanzania Network Against Alcohol (TAAnet), Tanzania
Rogers Kasirye, Executive Director, Uganda Youth Development Link (UYDEL)
Juliet Namukasa, Country Director, International Aid Services (IAS) Uganda
Pascaline Umulisa, Executive Secretary, Rwanda Girl Guides Association, Rwanda
Wilbert T Jena, Executive Director, For Youths By Youths, Zimbabwe
Mphonyane Mofokeng, Founder and Director, Anti Drug Abuse Association of Lesotho (ADAAL), Lesotho
Labram Musah, Programmes Director, Vision for Alternative Development (VALD), Ghana
Ibrahim Ahmed Kugblenu, Institute of Leadership and Development (INSLA), Ghana
Alagie B Janneh, National Coordinator, IOGT- Gambia and Chairman, Alcohol Policy Alliance Gambia (APAG), Gambia
Angelina Agau, CEO, Christian Action for Development & Support (CADS), South
Yong Kim Eng, President, PDP Center, Cambodia
Pubudu Sumanasekara, Vice President, Movendi International, and Executive Director ADIC Sri Lanka
Bolormaa Purevdorj, Population Health Research Center, Mongolia
Dayana Vincent, Director, Fourth Wave Foundation, Indian Social Institute, Benson Town, Bangalore, India
Mona Örjes, President, IOGT-NTO Movement, Sweden
Download the joint open letter (PDF)
For further reading
Carefully curated stories about alcohol policy in South Africa, on the News Center.